Among the world’s most congested cities are in India. My native Pune, within the western a part of the nation, is one among them. It is likely one of the two “Detroits” of India (the opposite being Chennai) with Tesla Indias company workplace, Mercedes-Benz and Tata Motors factories and a number of the worst site visitors wherever on the planet. The norm right here is that in case you see a gap, you drive into it. Oncoming automobiles, lane self-discipline or any rule of regulation can all go to hell. The MG Comet EV was born for the sort of mayhem.
To maintain transferring in such circumstances, you both experience a two-wheeler or soar into an auto-rickshaw (tuk-tuk), each of that are a lot much less comfy than vehicles and might be exhausting in your backbone. Nevertheless, if you wish to get round shortly and pretty comfortably, you may have to get artistic. Massive, typical vehicles are troublesome to drive via the chaotic streets. Enter microcars. These are small, light-weight and agile automobiles designed for city environments. Consider the Fiat Topolino and Citroen Ami in Europe, the discontinued Good Fortwo within the US or the Mahindra E2O in India. Lately, the MG Comet EV is the microcar that has turned heads within the nation.
Britain’s MG Motor, which is owned by China’s SAIC Motor, sells a number of EVs in India. The Comet EV is likely one of the newer and extra standard. This can be a badge designed model of the SAIC-GM-Wuling Air. However apart from that Wuling Air manufactured in China and Indonesia, the Comet EV is assembled in Gujarat, a state in western India. It begins at $8,000 (7 lakh rupees) and comes with a battery-as-a-subscription (BAAS) gross sales mannequin that allows you to lease the battery for a small month-to-month price, successfully reducing the acquisition worth.
So how is the MG Comet EV to drive? Is that worth too good to be true? For that cash, is it a compromise or one thing actually distinctive? I jumped behind his wheel to seek out out.
(Full Disclosure: Whereas I used to be on a private journey to India, MG Motor loaned me a Comet EV for one week. It arrived with a full cost and I returned it as nicely.)
34
Small resolution to an enormous downside
At simply 117 inches lengthy (2,947 millimeters), the Comet EV is half the dimensions of a BMW i7. Its stretched 79.1-inch wheelbase (2,010 mm) means all 4 wheels are on the excessive corners of the automotive, like a buggy. It rides on tiny 12-inch metal wheels – in regards to the measurement of a medium American pizza. At 59.2 inches vast (1,505 mm), it is about as vast as my dwelling workplace desk. It weighs 1,796 kilos (815 kilograms), about two-thirds the load of the Ultium battery within the GMC Hummer EV. A Mazda Miata weighs about 600 kilos extra.
Nonetheless, the cabin gives more room than you’d anticipate. I am 5′ 7” and had sufficient room within the second row to sit down behind a 6′ 3” buddy within the entrance seat. Tall passengers can really feel comfy within the entrance, however not within the again. The cabin can also be very slender, so tall adults could not benefit from the house as a lot.
Having 4 seats in such a small EV comes with some inevitable compromises: It does not have vital baggage house behind the rear seats or a trunk. The tailgate opens to sufficient room for a few laptop computer luggage and a charging cable. However with the rear seats down, there’s loads of room for 2 full-size suitcases. But its small measurement comes with an enormous persona.
The Comet EV turned heads in all places I went. Regardless of its shrunken dimensions, it exudes a premium and futuristic environment. The Apple Inexperienced paint stands out, however even the Sweet White I drove was no much less of a crowd magnet. The complete-width mild bars on each side look neat, with the headlights and taillights positioned above the entrance and rear bumpers. Throwing the headlamps at evening was improbable, nearly as good as a Tesla. The door appeared disproportionately massive, but it surely meant getting out and in was simple, even whenever you hopped within the again.
You possibly can drive as much as a five-star lodge and hand the keys to the valet with out feeling misplaced.
Smaller than a PHEV battery
That is the place issues get somewhat, erm… wayward. The Comet EV’s specs are overwhelming on paper. Its rear-axle-mounted electrical motor produces 42 horsepower and 81 pound-feet of torque (110 Nm).
The motor attracts energy from a 17.3 kilowatt-hour lithium-iron-phosphate (LFP) battery. A Toyota RAV4 plug-in hybrid will get an 18.1 kWh battery, for reference. The Comet EV’s battery is sourced regionally from Tata AutoComp, a part of the bigger Tata Group, which can also be the father or mother firm of Tata Motors and the homeowners of Jaguar Land Rover.
MG Comet EV Specs
As-tested worth
8,20,000 rupees ($9,500)
Base worth
7,00,000 rupees ($8,000)
Battery
17.3 kilowatt-hours (LFP)
Loading time
10-80% in 2.5 hours (7.4 kW charger)
Kind of cost
AC
Kind Drive
Rear wheel drive
Effectivity
6.5 miles per kilowatt hour (calculated)
EV collection
143 miles (230 kilometers)
Output
42 hp
Most torque
81 lb-ft (110 Nm)
Seat capability
4
Regardless of the tiny battery, the EV’s light-weight development means it nonetheless gives sufficient vary for town. MG says it could actually journey 230 kilometers (143 miles) on a single cost. It’s based mostly on the Automotive Analysis Affiliation of India (ARAI) take a look at cycle, which supplies overly optimistic effectivity figures like China’s CLTC or Europe’s WLTP. The vary can be a lot shorter on America’s stricter EPA cycle, however the MG needn’t fear about that.
I acquired a calculated effectivity of 6.5 miles per kilowatt hour. It’s based mostly on the vitality delivered by the charger, with out taking charging losses into consideration. The EV does not inform you the precise vitality consumed by the battery – so it is probably that the effectivity might be a bit higher. However based mostly on that determine, precise metropolis vary is round 112 miles on a single cost – greater than sufficient for a rustic the place the common each day driving distance is estimated at 21 miles.
Annoyingly, it does not DC cost shortly. So Stage 2 AC charging is all you might have. A ten-80% cost with a 7.4 kW dispenser takes about 2.5 hours. A 240-volt socket will take seven hours for a full 0-100% cost. With India nonetheless within the early adoption section of electrification, charging infrastructure was unclear. Oddly, there have been much more DC quick charging stations within the metropolis than Stage 2 plugs, which was irritating. I discovered a number of stage 2 chargers alongside the sting, however most had been vandalized and inoperable.
It Sends Like A Purchasing Cart
Driving the Comet EV round city felt like pushing a purchasing cart. Forty-two horsepower is terrible for an EV, but it surely’s ample for such a light-weight automotive. Eco mode limits the pace to a modest 50 mph (80 km/h), whereas Sport mode pushes it barely over 62 mph (100 km/h). The game mode did really feel shiny, with the MG even spinning its rear wheels beneath acceleration.
However the actual thrill comes from weaving via site visitors. Visitors jams are widespread in massive Indian cities, the place vast roads abruptly flip to single-lane paths. This implies automobiles use each inch of the highway. See a spot, and the comet slips via with ease. Mix that with immediate acceleration and it had me grinning ear to ear each time I pulled off the throttle. It appeared to be the quickest automotive on the town, leaving nearly each different non-two-wheeler within the rearview mirror.
The tiny 12-inch wheels and restricted suspension journey do not do a lot for experience consolation. Whereas the gentle setup cushions small undulations at low speeds, potholes over 30 mph ship jolts up your backbone and rattle the cabin. Plus, I did not really feel notably protected within the Comet, but it surely does get twin airbags and stability management. On the freeway, surrounded by tall vehicles and SUVs, the Comet’s small measurement made me really feel susceptible. It’s also inclined to harsh climate. With its “IP-67-rated water resistant battery,” it is unclear whether or not it could actually deal with water-clogged streets. I can also’t think about driving it via robust winds with the worry of being swept away.
In its pure habitat, nonetheless, the comet is king beneath ultimate climate. It was constructed for one factor—zero-emission metropolis driving—and it excels at it.
Infotainment and connectivity
The Comet EV boasts twin 10.25-inch screens—one for infotainment, the opposite for the gauge cluster. The central display screen is easy, with no lag or body drops. Wi-fi Android Auto ran with none gremlins. Whereas most features are managed by the touchscreen, it additionally will get bodily controls for local weather, drive modes and media, with extra controls on the steering wheel.
However the meter group is irritating. Regardless of its sizable 10.25-inch display screen, it gives little info, leaving a lot of that display screen measurement underutilized. You get the necessities: drive mode, pace, vary and battery share. However that is about it. The left facet shows voltage and present—virtually ineffective for on a regular basis driving. It might have been far more helpful to see the charging speeds and the quantity of vitality added right here.
On a brighter notice, the inside match and end was prime notch. Chrome trims on the gear selector knob, air vents and HVAC controls added a premium really feel. Nevertheless, the slender cabin leaves no room for cup holders within the heart console. As a substitute, they’re on the dashboard in entrance of the air vents—so good luck maintaining your espresso heat.
Pronunciation
The Comet EV’s beginning worth of $8,000 components in the price of the battery. However you possibly can select to lease the pack as an alternative for a small price per kilometer that’s lower than a greenback (2.5 rupees per kilometer), lowering its beginning worth by about $2,200. So, basically you solely pay for the car after which the space you drive after the acquisition.
However that mentioned, the Comet EV will not be an all-rounder. It’s removed from it. When parked, you possibly can simply rock it with one hand and watch it sway left and proper on its dampers—that is how light-weight it’s. It is nice for town, however not precisely confidence-inspiring for the freeway. His vary is solely ample. Load capability is lower than ultimate. Nevertheless, it shines in a single necessary space—via site visitors. It navigated town pretty comfortably, with room for grocery luggage, suitcases (with rear seats dropped), and ample digital connectivity.
It turned heads in all places I went. Hairdressers on the salon the place I usually walked out to test it out. My tailor was interested by it. My neighbors, family and friends could not cease asking about its worth and scope. This curiosity stems from a broader downside going through commuters – crippling site visitors congestion that appears to be getting worse day-after-day with no clear resolution in sight. It is no silver bullet to unravel that downside, but it surely’s one of many quickest, zero-emission and comfy methods to get round.
It is a one trick pony and a superb one at that.
Do you might have a tip? Contact the creator: suvrat.kothari@insideevs.com
AI IT SOLUTIONS – BLOG4CARS.COM
Subscribe Us.
Leave a Reply